| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Asher Young | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Pitcher | Neil Abbitiello | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Pitcher | Matt Quiridongo | New Rochelle Tigers |
| Relief Pitcher | Chris Calamari | New York Bears |
| Catcher | Mack Lauder | Somers Cyclones |
| First Base | Kevin Haag | Somers Cyclones |
| Second Base | Matt Webster | Somers Cyclones |
| Third Base | Chris Stern | East Coast Clippers |
| Shortstop | Josh Small | Somers Cyclones |
| Outfield | Ryan Popp | East Coast Clippers |
| Outfield | Javaun Smith | Somers Cyclones |
| Outfield | Andrew Gross | New York City Thunderdogs |
| DH | Armend Pushka | New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Utility | Jeff Sosa | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Utility | Brian Corporan | Westchester TSC |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Josiah Gray | Westchester TSC |
| Pitcher | Andrew Workman | New Rochelle Tigers |
| Pitcher | Mike Forgione | Peekskill Tides |
| Relief Pitcher | Christian Pimental | Westchester TSC |
| Catcher | Niko Haggerty | Westchester TSC |
| First Base | Griffin Dey | New York Bears |
| Second Base | Danny Pagliuca | New York City T-Dogs |
| Third Base | Matt Flannery | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Shortstop | Richard Zapata | Westchester TSC |
| Outfield | Dion Austrie | Westchester TSC |
| Outfield | Mark Shkrelja | Westchester TSC |
| Outfield | Ralph Nuzzi | New Rochelle Tigers |
| DH | Rich Barella | New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Utility | Robert Donnelly | New City Outlaws |
| Utility | Kumar Nambiar | New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Brandon Cohall | Peekskill Tides |
| Pitcher | VJ Collins | Harrison Patriots |
| Pitcher | Trey Pizzutello | New York Bears |
| Relief Pitcher | Dan Demetrops | New City Outlaws |
| Catcher | James Beck | New York Finest |
| First Base | Ian Osterman | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Second Base | Stephen Figueroa | Harrison Patriots |
| Third Base | Lou Miceli | New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Shortstop | Stephen Hill | Peekskill Tides |
| Outfield | Kyle Divico | New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Outfield | Fabio Ricci | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Outfield | Joe Anselmi | New City Outlaws |
| DH | Max Hegedus | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Utility | Vinny D'Ambrosio | Somers Cyclones |
| Utility | Anthony Gigante | New Rochelle Tigers |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Jared Bronley | New York Bears |
| Pitcher | Eric Bauer | Somers Cyclones |
| Pitcher | Mike Haag | Somers Cyclones |
| Relief Pitcher | Nick Soto | Peekskill Tides |
| Catcher | Mike Amaturo | Somers Cyclones |
| First Base | David Judisky | Peekskill Tides |
| Second Base | Joey Aiola | Somers Cyclones |
| Third Base | Chris Davis | Hastings Lookouts/Clippers |
| Shortstop | Matt Adipietro | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Outfield | Jake McGrath | New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Outfield | Nick Euvino | Harrison Patriots |
| Outfield | Tino Pardo | Rockland Cavs |
| DH | Alec Petrone | Somers Cyclones |
| Utility | Joe Tomasulo | Peekskill Tides |
| Utility | Joe Smith | Peekskill Tides |
| Position | First Team | Second Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Steve Marks--Danbury Barons | Keith Malanga-- Harrison Patriots |
| John Amodeo-- Peekskil Tides | ||
| Pitcher | Alex Farina--Danbury Barons | Rob Cahill--Rockland Cavs |
| Pitcher | Jimmy Sikorski--Wilton Warriors | Joe Randazzo-- Hastings Lookouts |
| Zach Levins-- Wilton Warriors | ||
| Catcher | Leo Bravo-- New Rochelle Tigers | Dan Morris-- New Rochelle Tigers |
| Richie Carbone--NYC TDogs | Tom McCarthy-- Rockland Cavs | |
| First Base | Brett Connors-- Wilton Warriors | |
| Andrew Coffey -- Danbury Barons | Tyler Colby-- Wilton Warriors | |
| Second Base | Kyle Clemmenson-- Somers Cyclones | Donny Castaldo-- Somers Cycloners |
| Matt Belitz--Somers Cyclones | Steve Laurino-- Peekskill Tides | |
| Third Base | Justin Sims-- Peekskill Tides | |
| Mike Yates-- Harrison Patriots | Spencer Judge-- Danbury Barons | |
| Shortstop | Charlie Galasso-- Somers Cyclones | |
| Brian Czel-- Wilton Warriors | Matt Reynolds-- Wilton Warriors | |
| Outfield | ||
| Taylor Stuart -- Danbury Barons | ||
| Outfield | ||
| Sam Young-- Wilton Warriors | ||
| Outfield | ||
| Donato Signore-- New Rochelle Dirtbags | ||
| Designated Hitter | Cristian Fiorito--New Rochelle Dirtbags | |
| Utility | Alex Adami--Somers Cyclones | |
| Utility | ||
| Relief Pitcher |
| Position | First Team | Second Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Mike Volpe -- Somers Cyclones | Ray Courtney -- Rye Patriots |
| Pitcher | Eric Cooper -- Hudson Mudcats | Brian Callahan -- Rockland Astros |
| Catcher | John Casten -- Rockland Astros | Nick Cutsumpas -- New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| First Base | Brendan Slattery -- Peekskill Tides | Andrew Camardella -- Rockland Astros |
| Second Base | Sean Lafaye -- New Rochelle Dirtbags | Mike McDonald -- Danbury Barons |
| Third Base | Kenny Post -- Rockland Astros | Chris Orlando -- New York Bears |
| Shortstop | Darwis Gonzalez -- Rockland Astros | Andrew Romanella -- Hudson Mudcats |
| Outfield | Gaston Rojas -- Danbury Barons | Kyle Cullen -- Rockland Astros |
| Outfield | Tyler Gurman -- Rye Patriots | Alex Hero -- Rockland Cavaliers |
| Outfield | James Dealto -- New York Bears | PJ Rinaldi -- Danbury Barons |
| Designated Hitter | Rich Reilly -- Hastings Lookouts | Brian Sullivan -- New Rochelle Tigers |
| Utility | Colin McCarthy -- Danbury Barons | Tyler Curry -- New York Bears |
| Relief Pitcher | Reid Terry -- New York Thunderdogs | George Savaides -- Danbury Barons |
| Relief Pitcher | Frank Luongo -- Rye Patriots | Chase Levi -- New York Bears |
| Position | First Team | Second Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Peter Ladis -- New Rochelle Dirtbags | Pat Considine -- Peekskill Tides |
| Pitcher | Dylan Joyce -- Rockland Cavaliers | Christian Bula -- Rye Patriots |
| Catcher | Anthony Arrichiello -- Rye Patriots | Mike Samela -- Danbury Barons |
| First Base | Chris Nardozzi -- Yorktown Brewers | Mike Gimblette -- Yorktown Brewers |
| Second Base | Pat Farina -- Hastings Lookouts | Martin Aranda -- New Rochelle Athletics |
| Third Base | Brett Gorman -- Somers Cyclones | Dan Mooney -- Rye Patriots |
| Shortstop | Frank Salerno -- Suffern Blue Devils | Will Baine -- Pleasantville Red Sox |
| Outfield | Carmine Caputo -- Peekskill Tides | Anthony Muccio -- New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Outfield | Ray Maggi -- Somes Cyclones | Bobby Migliazza -- Peekskill Tides |
| Outfield | Tony Negrin Jr. -- New Rochelle Athletics | Brian Nasti -- New Rochelle Athletics |
| Designated Hitter | Ryan Spicer -- Suffern Blue Devils | Joe DePool -- Suffern Blue Devils |
| Utility | Greg Kumpel -- Rockland Cavaliers | Matt DeSilva -- Rockland Cavaliers |
| Relief Pitcher | George Perrotta -- Peekskill Tides | Vincent Martorelli -- Suffern Blue Devils |
| Relief Pitcher | Jon Poplowski -- New York Thunderdogs | Ryan Fedak -- New Rochelle Dirtbags |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Ryan Fasano | Suffern Blue Devils |
| Pitcher | Rob Ardino | Eastchester Red Birds |
| Pitcher | Jake Menzo | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Catcher | Kevin Madison | Peekskill Tides |
| First Base | Jordan Kolinsky | Suffern Blue Devils |
| Second Base | Bryce Einhorn | Pleasantville Red Sox |
| Third Base | Nick Rossetti | New Rochelle Tigers |
| Shortstop | Will Greenberg | New York City Thunderdogs |
| Outfield | Nick Barbalato | Suffern Blue Devils |
| Outfield | Garrett Glashoff | Peekskill Tides |
| Outfield | Matt Maher | Peekskill Tides |
| Utility | Bobby Villante | Rye Patriots |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Kenny Smith | New York Monarchs |
| Pitcher | Mike Howard | Danbury Barons |
| Pitcher | Keith Krieg | Peekskill Tides |
| Catcher | Josh Corn | New York City Thunderdogs |
| First Base | Mike Tavares | Rye Patriots |
| Second Base | Andrew Rosario | New York Monarchs |
| Third Base | Justin Leon | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Shortstop | Matt Marrotta | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Outfield | Stephen Pinto | New Rochelle Tigers |
| Outfield | Mike Mobbs | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Outfield | Pat Furey | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Player | Position | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Mark Canner | Pitcher | New York Monarchs |
| Bobby Stockert | Pitcher | Rye Patriots |
| Scott Picerno | Pitcher | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Chris Paolercio | Catcher | Rye Patriots |
| Dan Silva | First Base | Rockland Cavaliers |
| Adam Pennacchio | Second Base | New York City T-Dogs |
| Nick Delzio | Third Base | Danbury Barons |
| Will Smith | Shortstop | New York City T-Dogs |
| Nick Maranino | Outfield | New Rochelle Tigers |
| Connor Thorp | Outfield | Danbury Barons |
| Anthony Muccioli | Outfield | Peekskill Tides |
| Player | Position | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Chris Lopez | Pitcher | Pleasantville Red Sox |
| Brent Morris | Pitcher | Danbury Barons |
| Vinny Martino | Pitcher | New City Outlaws |
| Mario Martinez | Catcher | New City Outlaws |
| Andy LeRay | First Base | Peekskill Tides |
| Chris Alleva | Second Base | Yonkers Indians |
| Ricky Gundert | Third Base | Somers Cyclones |
| Jorge Rosado | Shortstop | Brooklyn Falcons |
| Carlos Quintana | Outfield | Bronx Royals |
| Peter Allen | Outfield | Westchester Cubs |
| Nick Albano | Outfield | North Castle Lookouts |
| Joe DiLeo | Utility Player | Pleasantville Red Sox |
| Player | Position | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Roshawn Cherry | Pitcher | Brooklyn Falcons |
| Ben Hamm | Pitcher | New York City T-Dogs |
| Matt Kennedy | Catcher | Westchester Yankees |
| Lou Gigante | First Base | Yonkers Indians |
| Anderson Rivas | Second Base | New York Orioles |
| Jose Fulgencio | Third Base | Brooklyn Falcons |
| Chris Mentrasti | Shortstop | Westchester Cubs |
| Tommy Thulin | Outfield | Danbury Barons |
| Mike Oliva | Outfield | Yonkers Indians |
| Steve Sallustio | Outfield | New Rochelle Rockies |
| Charles LaLane | Utility Player | Brooklyn Falcons |
| Player | Position | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Sean Kahn | Pitcher | Tarrytown Lookouts |
| Derek Kelly | Pitcher | New York City T-Dogs |
| John Magaletti | Pitcher | New York Orioles |
| Griffin Occhigrossi | Pitcher | Danbury Barons |
| Dan Pineda | Catcher | Peekskill Tides |
| Alexander Brooks | First Base | Peekskill Tides |
| Neal Rosengren | Second Base | Peekskill Tides |
| Mike Shea | Third Base | Peekskill Tides |
| Jario Veras | Shortstop | New York Orioles |
| Dave Lopez | Outfield | New York City T-Dogs |
| Rich Coontz | Outfield | Tarrytown Lookouts |
| Rob Faist | Outfield | New York Orioles |
| Ciaran Crampton | Utility Player | New Rochelle Rockies |
