| Most Wins Season | Victories | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Mandile | 7 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2023 |
| Marc Denunzio & Joe Mandile & Scott Hannon | 5 | New York City Thunderdogs & New Rochelle Tigers & NY Finest | 2022 |
| Joe Mandile* | 10* | New Rochelle Tigers | 2021 |
| Joe Mandile | 8 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2019 |
| Joe Mandile | 6 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2018 |
| Joe Mandile | 5 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2017 |
| Mike Haag & Jake Menzo | 7 | Cyclones/Patriots | 2016 |
| Alex Conti | 8 | New City Outlaws | 2015 |
| Ken Frawley/Trey Pizzutello/Jake Menzo/Damien Myers | 6 | T-Dogs/Bears/Cavs/Tigers | 2014 |
| Frank Delgado/Matt Matcovitch/Ken Frawley/Pete Denyssenko | 6 | T-Dogs/ Outlaws/ Lookouts/ Patriots | 2013 |
| Frank Cebek & AJ Fagan | 7 | T-Dogs & Patriots | 2012 |
| Marc Casey | 8 | New City Outlaws | 2011 |
| Marc Casey | 8 | New City Outlaws | 2010 |
| Rob Ardino | 7 | Eastchester Red Birds | 2009 |
| Brendan O'Rourke/Scott Picerno/Brent Morris | 7 | Red Sox/Cavaliers/Barons | 2008 |
| Marc Casey | 9 | Yonkers Indians | 2007 |
| Marc Casey | 7 | Yonkers Indians | 2006 |
| Kevin Rettig* | 10* | Danbury Barons | 2005 |
| Chris Granata | 9 | New City Outlaws | 2004 |
| Josh Wifall | 9 | New York Monarchs | 2003 |
| Scali/Palanzo/Perlman/Berreta | 8 | Barons/Barons/Red Sox/Outlaws | 2002 |
| Justin Scali | 7 | Danbury Barons | 2001 |
| *League Record |
| Strikeout King | Strikeouts | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| TJ Fuerst | 50 | Westchester Statesmen | 2023 |
| Joe Mandile | 47 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2022 |
| Joe Mandile | 66 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2021 |
| Joe Mandile | 70 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2019 |
| James Puma | 60 | Somers Cyclones | 2018 |
| Robert Lichtenberger | 62 | Westchester TSC | 2017 |
| Frank Delgado | 55 | New York City Thunderdogs | 2016 |
| Mike Haag | 59 | Somers Cyclones | 2015 |
| Julio LaSalle | 63 | New York Finest | 2014 |
| Pete Denyssenko | 55 | Harrison Patriots | 2013 |
| Henry Hirsch | 69 | New York Bears | 2012 |
| Damien Myers | 71 | Pleasantville Red Sox | 2011 |
| Damien Myers | 87 | Pleasantville Red Sox | 2010 |
| Dan Murdoch* | 103* | Rye Patriots | 2009 |
| Kenny Smith | 82 | Hastings Monarchs | 2008 |
| John Magaletti | 71 | Yonkers Indians | 2007 |
| Chris Lopez/Chris Marin | 51 | Red Sox/Rockies | 2006 |
| Chris Marin | 81 | New Rochelle Rockies | 2005 |
| Derek Kelly | 87 | New York City Thunderdogs | 2004 |
| Rich Rubel | 89 | Danbury Barons | 2003 |
| John Robinson* | 103* | New York Knights | 2002 |
| Rich Rubel | 90 | Yonkers Yankees | 2001 |
| *League Record |
| ERA Title | ERA | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tyler Olmo | 1.98 | New City Outlaws | 2023 |
| David Richards | 1.42 | New York Bears | 2022 |
| Joe Mandile | 1.78 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2021 |
| Chris Calamari | 2.29 | New York Bears | 2019 |
| James Puma | 2.27 | Somers Cyclones | 2018 |
| James Puma | 0.87 | Somers Cyclones | 2017 |
| Mike Haag* | 0.29* | Somers Cyclones | 2016 |
| Alex Conti | 1.30 | New City Outlaws | 2015 |
| Damien Myers | 1.50 | New Rochelle Tigers | 2014 |
| Shawn Tarkington | 1.35 | Peekskill Tides | 2013 |
| Steve Marks | 1.38 | Danbury Barons | 2012 |
| Marc Casey | 1.85 | New City Outlaws | 2011 |
| David Gibbs | 2.03 | New York City Thunderdogs | 2010 |
| Ryan Fasano | 0.67 | Suffern Blue Devils | 2009 |
| Scott Picerno | 1.45 | Rockland Cavaliers | 2008 |
| Scott Picerno | 1.46 | Rockland Cavaliers | 2007 |
| Greg Palanzo | 0.54 | Danbury Barons | 2006 |
| Scott Perlman | 1.69 | Pleasantville Red Sox | 2005 |
| Scott Perlman | 1.74 | Pleasantville Red Sox | 2004 |
| Shawn Tarkington | 1.09 | Tarrytown Lookouts | 2003 |
| Greg Palanzo | 1.14 | Danbury Barons | 2002 |
| Frank Chibbaro | 0.95 | Tarrytown Lookouts | 2001 |
| *League Record |
| Saves Leader | Saves | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frank Fantino/Kevin Rettig | 2 | Outlaws/Tigers | 2023 |
| Kevin Watson | 5 | Somers Cyclones | 2022 |
| DJ Nakashima & Hector Vargas | 2 | Tigers/Finest | 2021 |
| Kevin Watson | 4 | Somers Cyclones | 2019 |
| Jack Reiss & Anthony Luciano | 3 | Somers Cyclones& New York Finest | 2018 |
| James Puma | 3 | Somers Cyclones | 2017 |
| Lou Miceli | 4 | New Rochelle Dirtbags | 2016 |
| David Balme* | 7* | Somers Cyclones | 2015 |
| Kyle Crimmins | 4 | Harrison Patriots | 2014 |
| Matthew Cresswell | 3 | New York Finest | 2013 |
| Alex Adami | 5 | Somers Cyclones | 2012 |
| Ryan Fedak* | 7* | New Rochelle Dirtbags | 2011 |
| Frank Delgado | 5 | New York City Thunderdogs | 2010 |
| Chris Denisar & Sean Kahn | 4 | Cavaliers/Lookouts | 2009 |
| Andrew Hargadon/Ben Hamm | 3 | Red Sox/Thunderdogs | 2008 |
| James Cisco | 4 | Pleasantville Red Sox | 2007 |
| John Magaletti | 6 | Yonkers Indians | 2006 |
| Mat Terrillion | 5 | Danbury Barons | 2005 |
| Jeff Emerich | 5 | Pleasantville Red Sox | 2004 |
| Ian Fairclough/Joel Perez | 4 | Rockies/Monarchs | 2003 |
| Paul Fahs | 4 | Carmel White Sox | 2002 |
| Chris DiScala | 5 | Tarrytown Lookouts | 2001 |
| *League Record |
